Skip to main content

Copyright over derivative works

I don't know, I don't think JK's really got a strong case here.
After all, it's just a reference guide to her work - she didn't write it, someone else (a librarian, woo-hoo!) put in that hard work.
I wonder, to take it to an extreme, if she wins this does it mean that travel writers won't be able to write about the countries they visit, because they didn't create them, just experienced them and loved them?
Assuming they even visited them in the first place, of course.

The case is being heard in America, and I'm not clear enough on UK copyright law (other than to know what I can and can't copy in a commercial library) to know if she'd be able to bring the same sort of case here. I have a feeling she couldn't but can't guarantee it.

Either way, I think she's perhaps getting a bit uptight about work created by people who love what she writes, and want to help guide others.

Comments

Unknown said…
I think the biggest problem JK has with this, is that it's mostly not original work. Most of what he is done is take her words and rearrange them. Somethings he has created (eg the timeline) but not the majority of what he's trying to publish.
Dumpling said…
The Times had a bit more detail on the content of the Lexicon, you're right, it seems like a lot of lifting has gone on, rather than actual creative writing on his own part.

http://entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/books/article3746505.ece

Popular posts from this blog

Library words

Putting words about libraries and books onto posters is very popular, so there's all sorts of options out there. These items are here because they have a quote or slogan about libraries or books printed on them. There's one quote in particular that seems to be a favourite of poster makers: see if you can spot which one it is.... Library bird (ok, it's a magnet, but hey...) Print Print Print Print Digital printable Hand-lettered quote Print Linocut block print Vinyl wall sticker Print Letterpress print Digital printable Print Print Linocut print Print Print

Mini Christmas gifts

Miniature things are one of my favourites, and miniature books are no exception. These tiny books are available either as volumes or sets of volumes on their own, or as parts of dolls house or in specialised miniature library settings. And some of the miniature libraries are just insanely good! I've not included here the many options of wearable miniature books - earrings, necklaces, bracelets, badges... A book with its own drawer for safekeeping Mini clay books Decorative mini books Ghosts in the library books Not exactly miniature, but very small "Little Leather Library" collection How about a Medieval illuminated book, in miniature? Or one with a secret compartment? There are even illustrated erotic mini books! You can theme by colour! Dollshouse insta-library (including 50 Shades of Grey, and the Hunger Games trilogies) Miniature haunted library Miniature Victorian library Still one of my favourites: themed mini

The library look - part two

Continuing the theme of art featuring libraries and librarians...let us pick up again where we left off.... In the rural library Shields library Original life portrait Library lion Birds nest In the library browsing Library freak Book lover At the library Library love Library gal Book lovers Read with me Book store girl Bath reading room Owls going to the library Sometimes, some other animals manage to creep into the library... Reading bear Bookworm